
Under what conditions is a mortgagee secure in proceeding
with a non-judicial foreclosure in Tennessee and other states when
land and a manufactured home are collateral? By Philip M. Kleinsmith,
Attorney Kleinsmith & Associates, P.C.
The Law: The State of Tennessee has no statute for making
a manufactured home part of the land it is on. Nonetheless, two Tennessee
Court of Appeals decisions and a decision of the Tennessee Bankruptcy
Court clearly state the conditions that must be present to make a
manufactured home part of such land (Associates Capital Corp. v. Cookville
Production Credit Association, 569 S.W. 2d 474(1978); Bank of Commerce
v. Waddell, 731 S.W. 2d 61 (1986), Roberts v. Green Tree Financial,
197 B.R. 86. These conditions are stated in the following paragraphs.
First, the manufactured home must be affixed to land ("Affixed").
This means that the axles must be removed and the manufactured home
must be put on a foundation and hooked-up to utilities as a normal
structure.
Secondly, the owner must own both the real estate and the manufactured
home ("Co-Owned").
Thirdly, there must be no liens on the title to the manufactured
home ("No Title Lien").
NOTE WELL: The legal arguments that support these
conditions are universal in every state. Therefore, these arguments
and the resulting conditions may well be used in other states that
do not have statutes to make manufactured homes part of such land
OR could be successfully used to make a manufactured home part of
such land when a manufactured home has not been made part of such
land in a state that does have such a statute.
Practical Effects: The usual circumstances where
this issue arises is when the mortgage lender decides to foreclose
pursuant to a non-judicial foreclosure process and discovers that
although the deed of trust or mortgage is recorded, the manufactured
home was not made part of such land by the process for doing so
(in states that have statutes), OR a lien was not put on the manufactured
homes motor vehicle title (If either of those procedures were followed,
both the land and the manufactured home can be foreclosed non-judicially.
(See UCC 9-604). In these circumstances, "Affixed", "Co-Owned"
and "No Title Lien" are facts that can be ascertained.
"Co-Owned" requires obtaining proof that your present
debtors now own both the real estate and the manufactured home.
Some reliable form of title work determines land ownership. The
owners of the manufactured home are obtained from a state agency
(Usually, you must have the Vehicle Identification Number. If you
do not have it, your problem becomes very difficult. If the present
debtors are not the manufactured home owners and will not sign the
title to you, only a judicial lawsuit can resolve the problem).
That search with the state motor vehicle department will also disclose
"No Title Lien" (If there is a lien to someone else, they
may release it because they have been paid. If they haven't been
paid, you must pay to get it released).
"Affixed" requires that a physical inspection must be
done. If the inspection discloses that the manufactured home is
"Affixed", an Affidavit of Affixture can be recorded (If
it is not affixed, a judicial lawsuit will be necessary).
The practical reality is that when you have proven (as above) that
the manufactured home is "Affixed", "Co-Owned"
and "No Title Lien" in Tennessee it is certain that you
can foreclose non-judicial. It is the author's legal opinion that
this is also true in other non-judicial states if these conditions
are fulfilled, even when the state involved has a statute allowing
a manufactured home to be made part of the land, which has not been
complied with.
Final Practical Point: However confident the author
may be of the above, the ultimate practical point is whether a title
company will insure title in a new owner (land and manufactured
home) after foreclosure. If they will, all is well. If they will
not, they are legally wrong, but practically, nothing can be done.
Consequently, before embarking on a non-judicial foreclosure of
land and a manufactured home, this must be determined. If they will,
all is well. If they won't, some form of judicial foreclosure will
be necessary.
|